×
  • remind me tomorrow
  • remind me next week
  • never remind me
Subscribe to the ANN Newsletter • Wake up every Sunday to a curated list of ANN's most interesting posts of the week. read more
You are welcome to look at the talkback but please consider that this article is over 2 months old before posting.

Forum - View topic
The Best and Worst Anime of Fall 2023


Goto page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6  Next

Note: this is the discussion thread for this article

Anime News Network Forum Index -> Site-related -> Talkback
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
JustMonika



Joined: 17 Jan 2022
Posts: 902
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 9:34 am Reply with quote
Best for me:

A Girl and Her Guard Dog
Girlfriend, Girlfriend S2
The 100 Girlfriends Who Really x5 Love You
Spy X Family S2
Our Dating Story: The Experienced You and Inexperienced Me
Shy
16bit Sensation: Another Layer
The Idolmaster: Million Live!

Worst:

JJK S2

Still need to watch:

Butareba
The Apothecary Diaries
Frieren: Beyond Journeys End
Shangri-La Frontier
I Will Survive Using Potions


Last edited by JustMonika on Sat Dec 23, 2023 3:00 pm; edited 3 times in total
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
killjoy_the



Joined: 30 May 2015
Posts: 2451
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 9:39 am Reply with quote
This season was a little weird to me because it kind of all fell within expectations, there's usually at least some surprise.

Stuff I had read the source

Frieren had an amazing start and some brilliant episodes, and doesn't have very good action arcs and slowly loses itself in its own cast of characters instead of focusing on the iyashikei nostalgia it does so well. My original thoughts when I read the manga back in September still perfectly line up, though the production elevates it enough that I'd consider the anime better than the manga (the post is in PT and has some very slight spoilers if you care) https://i.imgur.com/2t2afqZ.png. Best of the season for sure

Apothecary Diaries is as 'just ok' as the novel was. I feel like it eventually leads to some better payoff, but the anime won't get there with its current pace. The production is pretty, but I feel like it should've worked on the pacing instead. My original thoughts on the first LN https://anilist.co/activity/402960695

Love with the Villainess wasn't as fun as the first novel was, but given it only adapted that and not up to the second volume, which is what I feel made this series special, there wasn't too much they could do to make it better I guess other than being a bit too liberal in the adaptation and changing things. Still, the novel was a little better, I feel. My original thoughts on it https://anilist.co/activity/323141865

Sequels

Paladin is just as nice as it was before. Nothing too special, but the character writing somewhat consistently surprises in just being not cliché

Dead Mount just exacerbated the problems that the first cour had (feeling focusless) and stopped focusing on the good (Misaki's character being a lot more nuanced than the average Narita girl). Couldn't keep watching, and ended up being my only drop of the season. Worst of the season if we're counting drops

JJK S2 is better than the first season, but that's because I didn't like the first season. I liked the movie, and it's not as good as that - the Shibuya arc just starts way too slow, and even though it picks up near the end I feel like it wasted our times a bit too much

New stuff

Undead Unluck is really inconsistent, but it feels good seeing this production on something where the writing isn't as bad as Fire Force's (though it tries sometimes). The world is a lot more interesting than the average shounen I feel, while I'm not as much of a fan of the characters. If we're not counting drops for worst, then it's actually a three-way tie between this, Paladin and Apothecary, but I'm still kinda positive on all of them
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Hiroki not Takuya



Joined: 17 Apr 2012
Posts: 2497
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 10:05 am Reply with quote
Rebecca's thumbnail for "worst" perfectly conveys the reaction to Guard Dog... BLECH! But I'd keep my mouth tightly closed if I were that gurl, that tongue is too close...
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Hiroki not Takuya



Joined: 17 Apr 2012
Posts: 2497
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 10:17 am Reply with quote
To say Shield Hero S3 was the Worst seems a little unfair because there were definitely worse that aired, like Buteraba. Mind you, the latter had a great concept but was so poorly adapted and the LN so thin in material that it came our the worse for it. One point for trying?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
WizardOfOss



Joined: 19 Jun 2018
Posts: 76
Location: Oss, Netherlands
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 10:23 am Reply with quote
I'm still far behind with many shows as a result of a three week holiday to Japan, and because of that also dropped a bit more than I usually do.

Best is a battle between Frieren and Pluto. Can't decide yet, as one is still ongoing and the other I have yet to finish. But I can't imagine anything coming close to these two, not even AoT. And great to see some love here for Overtake!, but as much as I enjoyed it, it's just not at this level.

Worst will surely be MF Ghost, had this not been about cars I 100% would have dropped this. The protagonist might be the worst Gary Stu in anime history, the girl apparently became an Angel without having the tiniest clue about their role (and not even got a hint from the outfit she's wearing), and the racing only pretends to be realistic but is absolutely not. And even worse than that: Most of it is utterly boring. It's absolutely baffling to me that MFG scores (slightly) higher on MAL than Overtake. That's like a Porsche 718 beating a 911 GT3 RS....oh wait Rolling Eyes
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
tintor2



Joined: 11 Aug 2010
Posts: 1795
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 10:31 am Reply with quote
Guess Frieren really stole it. It felt to me like what To Your Eternity should have been in regards to themes and production values. Already Himmel's death in the first episode was sad as heck as it wasn't a single violent scene but instead a natural death which actually left a major impact in the narrative as it made Frieren realize the fragile human life. The next episodes were amazing thanks to its mix of action and slice of life moments. One thing, never marathon the series cos the flashbacks become more obvious than the ones from LOST. Frieren taking Fern and Stark was also a neat accomplishment considering how nice are their episodes but we have yet to see Sein's episodes.

Close I guess this season has been Spy X Family, but I wonder if wear nostalgia glasses for Captain Tsubasa. I also enjoyed Goblin Slayer but some excessive fanservice felt like the season was turning into an isekai (is the girl really called cow girl?!) About Jujutsu Kaisen there are things that bothered me besides Nobara's death. What's with the fake villain twist? How did Not Geto stole a body between the movie and first season? Why does Gojo gotta get sealed? He was the one of the funniest characters in the entire series. Then we have padding in fight scenes that don't add anything to the characters like Choso vs not Geto from yesterday.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Sekaro



Joined: 12 Nov 2018
Posts: 345
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 10:59 am Reply with quote
tintor2 wrote:
Why does Gojo gotta get sealed? He was the one of the funniest characters in the entire series. Then we have padding in fight scenes that don't add anything to the characters like Choso vs not Geto from yesterday.

If Gojo wasnt sealed, the arc would have been finished in less than a few episodes. The whole point of taking out an overpowered good guy character out of the equation is to create higher tension in its conflict. I thought that was pretty obvious. It also highlights the issues regarding Jujutsu society as a whole as everyone is becoming too complacent now as evident by the fact that they are ok with letting Gojo do all the heavy lifting, not knowing of the looming danger that came as a result of that.

I agree that Choso vs Not Geto felt like padding but it was still a pretty cool & well animated fight so i'm willing to overlook the padding.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Greed1914



Joined: 28 Oct 2007
Posts: 4408
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 11:02 am Reply with quote
If I had to pick a single best show of the season, then it's Frieren. That one came out strong and never really let go of the position. However, I think 100 Girlfriends deserves some special mention, which it did get in the article. I'm not going to tell you that a harem anime is going to be a genuine contender for anime of the year, but if you're a fan of the genre, this one is doing some unconventional things that make it stick out.

I have to agree with putting JJK as a most disappointing title. It didn't do anything that I would call particularly bad, and some of it is downright understandable with how things are going at MAPPA. The disappointing aspect to me is how much the Shibuya Arc does without giving chances for it to breathe and have weight. Big spectacle fights become almost forgettable when EVEN BIGGER spectacle fights immediately follow. Deaths of fan favorite characters get followed up by deaths of more fan favorite characters. It feels like the author had all these ideas, but couldn't decide where to put them, and so they ended up crammed into one arc.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Glordit



Joined: 11 Sep 2020
Posts: 423
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 11:06 am Reply with quote
e: oops! I didn't read the title.

Fall favorites:
Dekoboko Majo no Oyako Jijou
DR. STONE
Kusuriya no Hitorigoto
Sousou no Frieren
Shangri-La Frontier
Kamierabi
Kimi no Koto ga Dai Dai Dai Dai Daisuki na 100-nin no Kanojo
Megumi no Daigo: Kyuukoku no Orange
Migi to Dali
MF Ghost
Overtake
PLUTO
Ragna Crimson
Tearmoon Teikoku Monogatari: Dantoudai kara Hajimaru, Hime no Tensei Gyakuten Story
UNDER NINJA
Buta no Liver wa Kanetsu Shiro

Didn't really have that many I found boring:
Hoshikuzu Telepath
Kawagoe Boys Sing

Comments:
Shield Hero 3 and Goblin Slayer 2 didn't make any of the lists because, I was constantly back and forth with how I felt about it. Sometimes it was fun, others it felt like it was getting stale and they needed a reason to push the story along more.

I don't find Hikikomari Kyuuketsuki no Monmon boring but it too seems to flip flop between themes too often at times.

Butareba delved into some grim things later on but Project no.9 could not keep up with the schedule and the animation tended to tank hard in last few episodes, though I still am enjoying it.

Mig & Dali, UNDER NINJA and Ragna Crimson is absolutely wild, stupid and fun and I loved every second of it.

I think a lot of people looked over Kamierabi since it was CG, it had a rough start it started to develope quite an interesting story.

Bullbuster also didn't make the list, I will however say it was an enjoyable show for those who perfer stories about workplaces.

There's obviously a lot more but I'd be typing for days.

TL;DR Fall 2023 was very enjoyable, it had a lot of surprises.


Last edited by Glordit on Fri Dec 22, 2023 11:38 am; edited 6 times in total
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Key
Moderator


Joined: 03 Nov 2003
Posts: 18112
Location: Indianapolis, IN (formerly Mimiho Valley)
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 11:07 am Reply with quote
^
Glordit, that would be a list for the whole year. We're just talking about the Fall season here.

With as packed a season as this was, the diversity of these lists was expected.

Guess I've missed the boat on Scott Pilgrim (not at all familiar with and previous iteration of it) and am still left wondering how deep one has to get into 100 Girlfriends Who Really x5 Love You in order to start finding it so great; the three episodes I watched didn't overly impress me, and I've been watching harem anime since the early Tenchi Muyo! days. Still, people had talked about those two enough that seeing them pop up wasn't a surprise. Overtake! making an appearance really caught me off guard, though. That made so little initial impression on me that I almost forgot it was airing this season.

Frieren is my #1 pick for the season, and for pretty much the same reasons that Ricard and Gunawon state. (I also agree with Lynzee that Frieren herself can take a while to warm up to, but that makes her all the more satisfying a character in the long run.) I could also see reasonable arguments for any of Pluto, The Apothecary Diaries, The Ancient Magus' Bride s2p2 and maybe the AoT finale. The Eminence in Shadow s2 is good enough to be runner-up in most other seasons, but it just has too much competition this season.

Hiroki not Takuya wrote:
To say Shield Hero S3 was the Worst seems a little unfair because there were definitely worse that aired, like Buteraba.

I wholly agree that there were way worse shows this season than Shield Hero s3 (I'd classify it as mediocre, not bad), but I wouldn't put Buteraba among them. (I have found that one to be much more intriguing in the long run.) No, labeling anything other than The Kingdom of Ruin or A Girl and Her Guard Dog as the worst of the season is dong a disservice to the rest of the season's roster. (I could maybe see an argument for Berserk of Gluttony, too, since that's such a horrible adaptation of its source material; that would definitely be my Most Disappointing pick.)
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website My Anime My Manga
Glordit



Joined: 11 Sep 2020
Posts: 423
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 11:18 am Reply with quote
Key wrote:
^
Glordit, that would be a list for the whole year. We're just talking about the Fall season here.

With as packed a season as this was, the diversity of these lists was expected.

Guess I've missed the boat on Scott Pilgrim (not at all familiar with and previous iteration of it) and am still left wondering how deep one has to get into 100 Girlfriends Who Really x5 Love You in order to start finding it so great; the three episodes I watched didn't overly impress me, and I've been watching harem anime since the early Tenchi Muyo! days. Still, people had talked about those two enough that seeing them pop up wasn't a surprise. Overtake! making an appearance really caught me off guard, though. That made so little initial impression on me that I almost forgot it was airing this season.

Frieren is my #1 pick for the season, and for pretty much the same reasons that Ricard and Gunawon state. (I also agree with Lynzee that Frieren herself can take a while to warm up to, but that makes her all the more satisfying a character in the long run.) I could also see reasonable arguments for any of Pluto, The Apothecary Diaries, The Ancient Magus' Bride s2p2 and maybe the AoT finale. The Eminence in Shadow s2 is good enough to be runner-up in most other seasons, but it just has too much competition this season.

Hiroki not Takuya wrote:
To say Shield Hero S3 was the Worst seems a little unfair because there were definitely worse that aired, like Buteraba.

I wholly agree that there were way worse shows this season than Shield Hero s3 (I'd classify it as mediocre, not bad), but I wouldn't put Buteraba among them. (I have found that one to be much more intriguing in the long run.) No, labeling anything other than The Kingdom of Ruin or A Girl and Her Guard Dog as the worst of the season is dong a disservice to the rest of the season's roster. (I could maybe see an argument for Berserk of Gluttony, too, since that's such a horrible adaptation of its source material; that would definitely be my Most Disappointing pick.)


My bad! I got excited thinking it was the EoY version.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Gnarth



Joined: 06 Oct 2023
Posts: 175
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 11:21 am Reply with quote
Frieren eats all the competition this season. A stunning, smart, poignant, poetic, reflective, emotional masterpiece crowded with some of the best animation I've seen in recent years. Honorable mentions for Ancient Magus Bride and Apothecary Diaries, loved the first and loving the second. Really liked the AoT finale, but it doesn't really feel right to compare it to the rest for obvious reasons.

Worst is probably Kingdoms of Ruin that squashed every bit of promise it could ever have, and I agree with who called Jujutsu Kaisen the most disappointing. Not bad, but so much wasted potential.


Last edited by Gnarth on Fri Dec 22, 2023 11:24 am; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Minos_Kurumada



Joined: 04 Nov 2015
Posts: 977
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 11:24 am Reply with quote
At a conceptual level, there is nothing wrong with JJKS2.

The problem is that... its season 2, I feel we are missing 2 seasons of content to make me care about everything that's going on.

The fact that the show tried to use not one but 2 last minute flashbacks in order to make me care about the demise of one of the 3 main characters and still fail speaks by itself.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Oggers



Joined: 29 Nov 2017
Posts: 354
Location: Ontario, Canada
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 11:24 am Reply with quote
Best for me would be a tie between Frieren and Scott Pilgrim Takes Off. Like everyone else, I was caught off guard when it was revealed that the latter wouldn't be a straightforward adaptation of the original comics, but what we did get is just as enjoyable if not more so. It was great to see different takes on the characters this time around, and O'Malley's character designs translate extremely well to Science SARU's animation.

Runner-ups would be The Apothecary Diaries and Pluto, though that's mainly because I'm behind on both of them.

No worst, since as I've mentioned, I don't watch anime I know I won't like and I'm not big on hatewatching in general.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
flamemasterelan



Joined: 17 Apr 2022
Posts: 447
PostPosted: Fri Dec 22, 2023 11:25 am Reply with quote
tintor2 wrote:
I also enjoyed Goblin Slayer but some excessive fanservice felt like the season was turning into an isekai (is the girl really called cow girl?!)

So, an interesting little note about this is that it reminds me of when Nintendo was promoting Twilight Princess and they kept calling Link a "cowboy" in this game. In the interviews that followed, Aonuma and Miyamoto had to clarify that the Japanese understanding of a cowboy (or cowgirl , in this case) doesn't actually match up to the American one, and they basically think it refers to someone who works on a farm or ranch.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Reply to topic    Anime News Network Forum Index -> Site-related -> Talkback All times are GMT - 5 Hours
Goto page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6  Next
Page 1 of 6

 


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group